Posted on 21 Comments

Statement on #Catalonia by Some of the Enough is Enough Team

We are not exactly enthousiastic about states and nations. Not about new states and not about old states. In less than 24 hours there will be a public and binding referendum on Catalan independence from the Spanish state. We won’t jump on the nationalist bandwagon but we do see the ugly Francoist and fascist face of the Spanish state. After the massive wave of repression, which is ongoing, its not just about nationalism anymore.

barcelona29s

Published by Enough is Enough.

Note: Enough is Enough is not organizing any of  these events, we are publishing this text for people across the US and Europe to be able to see what is going on and for documentation only.

Read all our reports about Catalonia; here.

Statement on Catalonia by Some of the Enough is Enough Team

We are not exactly enthousiastic about states and nations. Not about new states and not about old states. In less than 24 hours there will be a public and binding referendum on Catalan independence from the Spanish state. We won’t jump on the nationalist bandwagon but we do see the ugly Francoist and fascist face of the Spanish state. After the massive wave of repression, which is ongoing, its not just about nationalism anymore.

Tomás Ibañez, the anarchist, was right when he wrote (in a letter to Miquel Amorós on September 26): “What has happened to some of the most combative sectors of Catalan society that have gone from ‘surrounding the Parlament’ in the summer of 2011 to want to defend the Institutions of Catalonia in September 2017?”

That many people are now celebrating the Catalan police (Mossos) is terrifying. It was the Mossos d’escuadra that cleared the Plaza Catalunya with an orgy of violence during the 15M occupation of the square in Barcelona in 2011. 

15M was the first movement which was able to mobilize large parts of Spanish society which questioned the political architecture of the “Regime of ’78”, named after the constitution of 1978. The so-called “transition” from the fascist Franco regime into a parlamentary democracy, left the Francoist political and military class untouched and actually was just a reform of the Franco regime. On October 9, 1976 former Francoist minister Manuel Fraga founded the People’s Alliance  (Alianza Popular, AP). Fraga authorized the execution of political prisoners under the Franco regime. A notable case is the execution of communist leader Julián Grimau, whom he called “that little gentleman” (Spanish: ese caballerete) in a press conference when asked about his detention and death sentence. Fraga was also one of the writers of the new Spanish constitution which was approved in 1978 and was never charged for the crimes he committed during the Franco years.

The now governing Partido Popular (PP) of prime-minster Mariano Rajoy was a re-foundation (in 1989) of the People’s Alliance (Alianza Popular, AP), again founded by Manuel Fraga. The 15M mobilizations made the political establishment increasingly nervous. Demonstrations were surpressed with police violence and the political class also reacted with new repressive and authoritarian laws like the “Ley Mordaza” (Gag law). With this law the cops are the ones who can charge and punish people for civil disobedience, without any form of interference or verdict by the courts.

A lot has happened since the massive 15M mobilisations across Spain in 2011 and 2012. In May 2017 we republished a piece by Autonomies about 15M in which Tomás Ibáñez stated that the “worst that could have happened to 15M, and the future of social struggle, would have been for it to have allowed itself to be led by the libertarian movement … or that it have assumed as its own the principles and objectives of the the libertarian movement.” (Ibáñez, Anarquismos a contratiempo, 269)  The “worst” thing, he qualifies, excluding 15M ending up in the hands of some left-wing, extreme left-wing or nationalist political parties. The rise of Podemos would seem to confirm the worst. The Spanish streets were empty again.

But not in Catalonia. The independence movement was already growing but the end of the massive 15M mobilizations and the rejection by the Spanish Constitutional Court, at the request of Rahoy’s Partido Popular, of a draft Regional Statute approved by the Catalan courts, was also the start of an enormous boost for the struggle for independence. The regional Catalonian political class became under pressure after social movements and large parts of society demanded the right to decide about the independence of Catalonia. As a result many politicians started to support the project of an independent state.

After the Catalan government announced to held a referendum for independence on the first of October, the Spanish state reacted with a wave of repression. Regional government buildings were raided, ballot boxes confiscated and thousands of riot cops and paramilitary Guardia Civil squads were send to Catalonia by the central government. The .cat domain registration office was raided, websites and google apps banned just to name a few of the measures taken by Rajoy’s central government in Madrid. Rajoy again and again stated that the referendum about the independence of Catalonia will not take place.

Given the wave of repression by the Spanish state many anarchist comrades in Catalonia will support the struggle against repression and for the right of self-determination and freedom of information. Many of them will do so although they are not supporting the idea of another state.

We don’t believe in new states, especially not within a capitalist framework. We are convinced that we need an anti-capitalistic social transformation where production, consumption and decision-making are self-organized and in the hands of the people, a social transformation without states and borders. But we also can’t look away when the Spanish state is showing its ugly fascist Francoist face and repress people. We can’t look away when basic rights like the freedom of information and the right to determine peoples political will is being attacked by the authoritarian government in Madrid. 

The opinions of anarchist comrades in Catalonia are mixed. While some people think that Catalonian independence is an opportunity to boost the struggle for social and emancipatory issues in a new and possibly unstable state (at least in the beginning), others think that the struggle for independence is distracting from these struggles. There should be no doubt about the objectives of the neoliberal ruling class in Catalonia. As soon as they do not need the social movements anymore, they will be the first to repress the emancipatory forces in the movement. We are not very optimistic but will support the struggle against repression and for social transformation as good as we can. In Catalonia and elswhere.

Some of the Enough is Enough team will travel to Catalonia soon to support and cover the developing situation. But we your need support to be able to report from the ground. (You can read how you can support our work; here or support our crowdfunding campaign: here.)

In solidarity, some of the Enough is Enough team, September 30, 2017




cropped-enoughisenough3.png

enoughcrowdfundingHelp maintain our site and continue our work: Donate

We want to stay independent and want to expand our work with coverage from on the ground across Europe and even beyond.  Therefore we need your support. Help maintain our site and continue our work.

You can donate on our Paypal account: enough14@gmx.net

Crowdfunding campaign: https://www.youcaring.com/enough14solidarity

21 thoughts on “Statement on #Catalonia by Some of the Enough is Enough Team

  1. Breaking up a Francoist fascist state is always a good thing.

  2. Anarchist graffiti campaign against the Monarchists and the Republicans in Barcelona, throughout September 2017.
    Since you’ve been posting quite a bit of ‘Catalan Indep’ stuff, mostly pro-republican, it’d be cool if you shared this too:

  3. Fuck PayPal. I can help you raise funds in Bitcoin. Drop me a mail: x_at_ome.ga

    1. We tried to mail you but the email adress didn’t work…

  4. […] of this present moment in Catalonia. Further reading and listening on this in English can be found here and […]

  5. […] 11:00am Read our statement from September 28: Statement on #Catalonia by Some of the Enough is Enough Team […]

  6. […] is very difficult for many anarchist comrades in Catalonia. Many people have a similar position as we have on the independence issue. They went on the streets on October 1, trying to protect people […]

  7. […] Catalonia  is very difficult for many anarchist comrades in Catalonia. Many people have a similar position as we have on the independence issue. They went on the streets on October 1, trying to protect people against […]

  8. […] our more detailed statement from September 30, we already stated that we are not exactly enthousiastic about states and nations. Not about new states and not about old st…. For us social struggle and the struggle for a society free of hierarchy with equal rights for all […]

  9. […] our more detailed statement from September 30, we already stated that we are not exactly enthousiastic about states and nations. Not about new states and not about old st…. For us social struggle and the struggle for a society free of hierarchy with equal rights for all […]

  10. […] our more detailed statement from September 30, we already stated that we are not exactly enthousiastic about states and nations. Not about new states and not about old st…. For us social struggle and the struggle for a society free of hierarchy with equal rights for all […]

  11. […] letters and statements from anarchists about the situation in Catalonia, many of them, including our own statement, opposing the idea of another […]

  12. […] letters and statements from anarchists about the situation in Catalonia, many of them, including our own statement, opposing the idea of another […]

  13. […] letters and statements from anarchists about the situation in Catalonia, many of them, including our own statement, opposing the idea of another […]

  14. […] our statement from September 30, one day before the Catalan referendum, we already wrote that “we are not exactly […]

  15. […] Καταλονία, πολλές από αυτές, συμπεριλαμβανομένης καιτης δήλωσής μας, που αντιτίθεται στην ιδέα ενός άλλου […]

  16. […] our statement from September 30, one day before the Catalan referendum, we already wrote that “we are not exactly enthousiastic […]

  17. […] the things the Catalan and Spanish ruling classes did yesterday. But first we want to stress that we are not in favour of any state. We consider states to be part of the […]

  18. […] We want to stress once again that we are not in favour of any borders and any old or new states. You can read more about our position on the Catalan process in this statement of September 30, 2017: here. […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.